PVP Avanced & HSSR - Feedback
#26
Posted 18 July 2010 - 06:37 AM
*too much disparity between classes and documentation. You'll need to make sure the wiki is updated with the proper links and info if you're going to be merging WOLFPACKS with the ADVANCED
*explanations of warp bubble mechanics were awesome and worth the money for the class
*the first day of class, the Advanced class, didn't require us to be in system really since we didn't do anything hands on. I could of been doing something else while listening to class, like bringing my roam ships into system. Maybe tell the fleet to "be at ease" and just be back at a certain time if needed
**Good class all around. Caldak does an excellent job of corralling us all
#27
Posted 18 July 2010 - 02:33 PM
I would recommend a slight break from pure class in the first advanced part with a roam for the scanning re-iteration, the HSSR class was very informative. Roam-wise I did enjoy the autonomy of it, ie thinking for self which was demonstrated once in the fight. I would also suggest students to have been given access to wolfpack reading as well. But since it was a 'one-off' kinda deal I greatly appreciate being given the opportunity to join an advanced session and my appetite for more pvp classes of more diversity is stronger than ever. Many thanks Caldak and Agony Unleashed. Byl..
BASIC-20100417
ALUMNI-BASIC-20100702
ADVANCED HSSR -1807102100
#28
Posted 18 July 2010 - 03:23 PM
#29
Posted 18 July 2010 - 03:52 PM
For anyone that missed them:The Co2 Tears from Gigx was priceless.
[blockquote][ 2010.07.18 01:17:01 ] gigX > tomorrow we come and took all your stations
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:10 ] gigX > and remove you from region
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:15 ] gigX > think about that
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:20 ] gigX > because I thinking already
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:23 ] Altaieere > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:30 ] gigX > it will be tap tap to empire
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:37 ] Altaieere > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:38 ] Vora Dumem > tap tap 'n' stuff
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:38 ] Caldak > Willing to Dance?
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:40 ] Alias Forgotten > TAP
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:41 ] gigX > and you will realy be agony empire
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:42 ] Rakasha Mara > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:43 ] A PECK > tapadee tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:45 ] keacte > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:52 ] Sebastien Saintfrusquin > shut up, people are trying to sleep here !
[ 2010.07.18 01:17:59 ] Alias Forgotten > tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:18:22 ] Stein Voorhees > I can't tap on stumps
[ 2010.07.18 01:18:39 ] Gingger > clump clump?
[ 2010.07.18 01:18:46 ] Stein Voorhees > Something like that
[ 2010.07.18 01:19:06 ] keacte > stomp tap stomp tap << man with limp
[ 2010.07.18 01:19:21 ] Gingger > pirate ctn maybe?
[ 2010.07.18 01:19:59 ] gigX > Caldak
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:06 ] gigX > no need to convo me
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:06 ] Caldak > yes?
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:11 ] gigX > you will see
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:20 ] gigX > your stations burning
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:26 ] Altaieere > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:38 ] Andalion Fey > Tap tap indeed.
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:38 ] Caldak > Was going to ask if you lot are up for another fight, but I think we spanked you too hard and you won't come fight
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:54 ] Lorn Raffa > oh, tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:54 ] gigX > its 3:20 am here
[ 2010.07.18 01:20:58 ] Gingger > givf us freki's pls
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:02 ] Gingger > and we will go
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:02 ] gigX > come tomorrow early
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:09 ] Rakasha Mara > tap spank tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:12 ] Kazuma Matsuki > things don't burn in space...
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:15 ] gigX > freki lol
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:16 ] Caldak > see even I can think of a good excuse to stay up another 5 min .. lol
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:20 ] gigX > even with freki
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:28 ] gigX > you will buy match on at
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:36 ] gigX > shame alliance
[ 2010.07.18 01:21:41 ] gigX > thats the name for you
[ 2010.07.18 01:22:17 ] Altaieere > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:22:45 ] Andalion Fey > Tap tap indeed.
[ 2010.07.18 01:23:07 ] Gizznitt Malikite > tap tap, 3b machariel, tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:23:55 ] gigX > wrong
[ 2010.07.18 01:23:58 ] gigX > it was 4+
[ 2010.07.18 01:24:00 ] Leucippus > tap tap
[ 2010.07.18 01:24:15 ] Caldak > Knoock Knock
[ 2010.07.18 01:25:05 ] MoHawk Nephilium > ding dong...
[ 2010.07.18 01:25:27 ] Vora Dumem > who is there?
[ 2010.07.18 01:25:38 ] Alexsr > aj kuci razlaz
[ 2010.07.18 01:25:49 ] Caldak > So just a quick yes or no, is it worth while staying for a fight, or do you wait for stragglers to come back before you undock ?
[ 2010.07.18 01:26:42 ] Fedijken > C02 IS lighter than hot air
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:14 ] gigX > come to our prime time
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:25 ] gigX > 19 eve
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:37 ] Gizznitt Malikite > good to know... we will try
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:41 ] gigX > no need
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:41 ] Gingger > tap tap?
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:42 ] P8REIT > Fedijken > C02 IS lighter than hot air - Comes from a noob - You have more to learn about everyting in eve there kid before you should talk smack
[ 2010.07.18 01:27:45 ] gigX > I will come to you
[ 2010.07.18 01:28:02 ] gigX > no need to come I will come
[ 2010.07.18 01:28:15 ] ROXGenghis > fap fap
[ 2010.07.18 01:28:17 ] Caldak > K we at the LF gate
[ 2010.07.18 01:29:04 ] Alexsr > we at 8p9
[ 2010.07.18 01:29:41 ] Rehtom Lamina > btw pro scouted guardian earlier
[ 2010.07.18 01:31:26 ] Gingger > o/ gf earlier hf sleep well
[ 2010.07.18 01:31:35 ] EVE System > Channel changed to LF-2KP Local Channel[/blockquote]
CCP Wrangler
#30
Posted 18 July 2010 - 04:23 PM
MORAL, adj. Conforming to a local and mutable standard of right. Having the quality of general expediency.
#31
Posted 18 July 2010 - 07:34 PM
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?214306]WOLFPACKS-201008281800[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]ADVANCED & ADVANCED HSSR Combo -1807102100[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?232075]Covops - 281101800
[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?243718]SKIRMISH-20110129
[/link]
#32
Posted 18 July 2010 - 07:46 PM
Logistics: As everyone said, the guardians did a fantastic job. I learnt the beautiful synergy guardians repping blackbirds can achieve. As a blackbird, I got aggro from 3 ships early in the battle, and had two flights of combat drones on me. Now the bubblers popped 3-4 bubbles around the fight, so staying aligned to a celestial for a quick warp out was not an immediate option. I had to depend on the guardians to keep me alive and jamming. Simon (guardian) did an awesome job by keeping me target locked even before the fight started. After a while, they realised there was no point attacking me, and switched targets. Things went a bit haywire after Caldak got primaried and they brought in more ships. Logistics could not keep up, and none of the guardians had my blackbird locked. For a while that was quite justified since no one was attacking me while I was merrily jamming ships. Meanwhile, I turned on my ab and tried to find my way out of the bubbles, so I could warp out if needed. However, i soon got a flight of combat drones on me. Think the 4bil machariel started shooting at me as well. I missed two jam cycles on him, and he had locked me now. I'd gotten quite a few jams on him since the start of the fight, and no doubt he was pissed. I broadcast for armor, but I went down in 10 secs. I think another blackbird went down at roughly the same time.
I really appreciate Simon taking the initiative to keep me alive initially. Next time can we pair up bb's with guardians? Yes I know to broadcast for reps, but bb's always get primaried and can't tank at all. By the time the blackbird gets locked and a rep cycle completes, it will likely be dead. Perhaps each guardian could be paired up with a blackbird, and it's the bb pilot's responsibility to stay in range to get repped. Or should blackbirds just focus on getting the hell out of bubbles, everything else becoming secondary? x) This is less about saving my ship, and more about keeping the ecm alive on field and reducing the incoming dps. Case in point, a few minutes later when my pod was warping to a safespot, I heard someone shouting, 'we can't tank this!' etc.
tl;dr Each blackbird should have a guardian as a buddy, making each other's jobs much easier.
#33
Posted 18 July 2010 - 10:51 PM
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com//e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?189530]BASIC - 20100417[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?214306]WOLFPACKS-201008281800[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/////e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]Combo Advanced/Advanced HSSR - 1807102100[/link]
SEMINARS:
[link=http://agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?164784.0]FC BASIC - 20091114 (asynchronous)[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?199338]The FC's Eyes in PVP - 20101605[/link]
SPECIALIST CLASSES:
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/////e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]HSSR - 1807102100[/link]
[link=http://eveboard.com/pilot/CSM_Barret][/link]
#34
Posted 19 July 2010 - 01:29 AM
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?180178.40#post_181107]BASIC-20100220[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]ADVANCED HSSR-1807102100[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?225860]Alumni Roam[/link]
#35
Posted 19 July 2010 - 04:00 AM
wow thank you SkrewedUp totally intend to take you up on that offer next wolfpacks i see up. and far as i can see whatever classes agony offers are well worth the time and isk spent on them. the information learned has made me alot better of a player and added alot of confidence to my pilotingWe have internally been considering removing the wolfpacks class and just having Basic, Advanced and then specialized advanced classes. But I think that we leave too many things out when we do that.
Thus wolfpacks will return with some changes. We'll still have the focus on bookmarking and scanning/recon but will add in a new section specifically on bubbles. Anyone that has come to this Advanced class is welcome to come to that next wolfpacks for free (just reference that you will be coming as alumni and this class in your enrollment).
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?214306]WOLFPACKS-201008281800[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]ADVANCED & ADVANCED HSSR Combo -1807102100[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?232075]Covops - 281101800
[/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?243718]SKIRMISH-20110129
[/link]
#36
Posted 19 July 2010 - 07:18 AM
I was one of the blackbird pilots in the fight, with a char is just under 5 months old. I fitted a 1600mm plate+dcu2. I normally fly caldari, so my armor tanking skills suck.
Because you weren't using any EANM and because the armor increase by using an armor plate is a fixed number that is not affected by skills, being a low skilled player has very little affect on your armor tank in a blackbird that is being remotely repped.
Logistics: As everyone said, the guardians did a fantastic job. I learnt the beautiful synergy guardians repping blackbirds can achieve. As a blackbird, I got aggro from 3 ships early in the battle, and had two flights of combat drones on me. Now the bubblers popped 3-4 bubbles around the fight, so staying aligned to a celestial for a quick warp out was not an immediate option.
... the machariel started shooting at me ... I missed two jam cycles ... I broadcast for armor, but I went down in 10 secs. I think another blackbird went down at roughly the same time.
Flying a blackbird with a fleet is often a suicide mission. Your blackbird cannot tank an enemy fleet. Two low slots just isn't enough. Your buffer tank is there to buy time for you to get away or simply last a little longer before you pop.
Things to do:
1) Get out of bubbles (if you have engineering V you have just enough PG to fit a 1600mm plate & a MWD+jammers => but no weapons. This shouldn't bother you. Weapons are the last thing you worry about fitting on a support ship.) A MWD helps you get out of bubbles much much faster than an AB.
2) Keep range on the fight
3) Stay aligned & warp out when you start taking damage
4) Return to the fight (at range whenever possible)
I really appreciate Simon taking the initiative to keep me alive initially. Next time can we pair up bb's with guardians? Yes I know to broadcast for reps, but bb's always get primaried and can't tank at all. ...
tl;dr Each blackbird should have a guardian as a buddy, making each other's jobs much easier.
Having the situational awareness to know who will be primary and preparing to rep them ahead of time is indicative of a good logistics pilot.
But; logistic pilots are flying 100m+ ships and their pre-locks & watch list are usually prioritized with the other logistics pilots. Also, logistics are primaried just as (if not more often) than ECM ships.
It would be nice to "pair up", but adding extra stuff like this can be difficult for an inexperienced logistics pilot. There are so many things that they already have to manage; checking broadcasts; watching other logistics on their watch list. turning on & off reps on multiple targets. transferring cap with their cap buddy. switching cap buddies if theirs is killed/bugs out. Staying in range of the fleet so they can continue to give reps. Staying out of range of the enemy fleet. Sometimes injecting cap. Etc.
And at the end of the day, a 5-10m T1 blackbird just doesn't get the same priority as a 100-150m T2 logistics ship.
If you're not having fun you're doing it wrong.
#37
Posted 19 July 2010 - 11:22 AM
The only feedback i can squeeze out of myself is, with "themed" ship names, it can be a bit hard to tell whether a ship name is "themed" or not. I was a bit puzzled whether, say, a ship named "Stiletto" (an actual BC) is shoe-related.
Yeah that would have been me, cane was called "Not Stilettos". I didn't consider people who have English as a second language - your English is better than most UK people however - so its actually a good thing to bring up.
Stiletto Heel in case you're still at a loss - women generally just call the whole shoe stiletto. Not something you'd necessarily understand now I come to think of it.
MORAL, adj. Conforming to a local and mutable standard of right. Having the quality of general expediency.
#38
Posted 19 July 2010 - 03:08 PM
Because you weren't using any EANM and because the armor increase by using an armor plate is a fixed number that is not affected by skills, being a low skilled player has very little affect on your armor tank in a blackbird that is being remotely repped.
I was using a best named 1600mm+dcu2, which gave me 14.2k ehp as opposed to the best named eanm 11.9k ehp. I don't have hull upgrades V for the t2 eanm. I could gotten higher ehp with an LSE+t2 hardener, but we did not have any shield logistics, and would have removed two low slots (edit: mid slots). Plus the 2x jamming rig downside would have reduced my shield hp as well.
I went in knowing it would be a suicide mission flying a blackbird. lol, I'm more upset by the fact that we got only one large fight, and I still have two spare blackbirds gathering dust in Esa with no fights in their history. Before the class, I debated a lot whether to fit a mwd. I have energy mgmt 4 and energy sys oper 4, so my cap skills are not fantastic. Even using best named jammers, I need a lot of cap to keep them going. However, when using an ab, I am cap stable with the ab turned off. Yeah I know that's no big deal. I also went cheap and fitted t2 caldari jammers which eat more cap :@. I also had an auto-targeting system which ate some cap too. Guess fitting a y-t8 mwd would have been a better idea, and I should have kept the high slots unpopulated. I was afraid of blowing up my sig radius from 150m base and dying+running out of cap before I got out of the bubble.Flying a blackbird with a fleet is often a suicide mission. Your blackbird cannot tank an enemy fleet. Two low slots just isn't enough. Your buffer tank is there to buy time for you to get away or simply last a little longer before you pop.
Things to do:
1) Get out of bubbles (if you have engineering V you have just enough PG to fit a 1600mm plate & a MWD+jammers => but no weapons. This shouldn't bother you. Weapons are the last thing you worry about fitting on a support ship.) A MWD helps you get out of bubbles much much faster than an AB.
2) Keep range on the fight
3) Stay aligned & warp out when you start taking damage
4) Return to the fight (at range whenever possible)
I should also have been much more concerned about exiting the bubble, and probably overheated my ab to do so right at the start of the fight. This was not the first blackbird I've lost in a fight. But this time I stupidly thought, we have guardians, so blackbirds can actually tank now! Since most of our fights take place near a gate, I did not fit for jamming range, just strength (7.9 each, 9.1 overheated). Still, did not make use of the 58km optimal + 65km falloff.
On a weird note, I still don't understand how heat damage spreads. I place my ab right in the centre, with my jammers surrounding it. Yet after the initial 2 cycles of overheating jammers, my ab took more heat damage than the actual jammers I was overheating! Another mistake I made was I forgot to repair my ab after the initial jammer overheat, even though I was carrying paste.
I fit the BB's to be a bit more expensive (17mil), but the guardians were the most valueable ships we were fielding. A bb should never get priority over 100mil+ guardians repping each other. Besides, the guardians need to maintain a cap chain and would always have each other locked no matter what. The idea is that longer the bb's stay alive, the easier life becomes for the guardians (and everyone else).But; logistic pilots are flying 100m+ ships and their pre-locks & watch list are usually prioritized with the other logistics pilots. Also, logistics are primaried just as (if not more often) than ECM ships.
...
And at the end of the day, a 5-10m T1 blackbird just doesn't get the same priority as a 100-150m T2 logistics ship.
#39
Posted 19 July 2010 - 03:21 PM
I fit the BB's to be a bit more expensive (17mil), but the guardians were the most valueable ships we were fielding. A bb should never get priority over 100mil+ guardians repping each other. Besides, the guardians need to maintain a cap chain and would always have each other locked no matter what. The idea is that longer the bb's stay alive, the easier life becomes for the guardians (and everyone else).
As a guardian pilot I wish more people understood this about logistics ships. Our first priority (like any pilot) is to stay alive and that may mean that we either have to get out or keep the other logistics pilots up instead of the combat pilots. With that said, I've probably sacrificed more logistics ships trying to get that last bit of repping than any other ship.
Repping blackbirds can be extra tough. Given the cycle times on the reppers, if you just have one rep on a bb it's probably going to go down before the cycle ends. You often want two or three that are staggered but in a heavy fight that is often impossible.
#40
Posted 19 July 2010 - 03:22 PM
lol... also the Stiletto is an Interceptor...
The only feedback i can squeeze out of myself is, with "themed" ship names, it can be a bit hard to tell whether a ship name is "themed" or not. I was a bit puzzled whether, say, a ship named "Stiletto" (an actual BC) is shoe-related.
Yeah that would have been me, cane was called "Not Stilettos". I didn't consider people who have English as a second language - your English is better than most UK people however - so its actually a good thing to bring up.
Stiletto Heel in case you're still at a loss - women generally just call the whole shoe stiletto. Not something you'd necessarily understand now I come to think of it.
Othran's point is valid, though, maybe we should have been clearer on that the ship name should contain the actual word shoe or something...
In wildness is the preservation of the world,
so seek the wolf in thyself
#41
Posted 19 July 2010 - 06:42 PM
Simon is me btw; I had the other logistics, Caldak and the Blackbirds on my watch list, and was trying to keep the BBs up - I'm glad it worked, although I'm sure the other logistics pilots were repping their hearts out too! :-)Simon (guardian) did an awesome job by keeping me target locked even before the fight started
As the fight progressed the enemy was doing a good job of spreading damage (it seemed to me they were even firing a single volley into a ship to alpha the shield and take a bit of armour (and cause a broadcast to go out), before moving on); it got quite hectic switching reps amongst those taking damage.
I had to unlock people who had stopped taking damage (anyone with shield charging basically) in order to keep up, and you must've got lost somewhere along the way. As others have pointed out though it was always going to be difficult keeping a BB alive with it's relatively thin buffer.
CCP Wrangler
#42
Posted 19 July 2010 - 07:04 PM
Repping blackbirds can be extra tough. Given the cycle times on the reppers, if you just have one rep on a bb it's probably going to go down before the cycle ends. You often want two or three that are staggered but in a heavy fight that is often impossible.
Are light armor maintenance drones are better for blackbirds? Guardian bonus for logistics drones means they rep twice as much. They have a 5s cycle time, so staggering reps is not an a problem. 3-4 light drones could probably have done the job. I had considered fitting small smartbombs on the high slots (could have squeezed in 3 max) to take care of drones, but did not want to accidentally destroy logistics drones repping me.
#43
Posted 19 July 2010 - 08:07 PM
#44
Posted 19 July 2010 - 09:30 PM
#45
Posted 19 July 2010 - 09:37 PM
#46
Posted 19 July 2010 - 10:13 PM
Alumni: WOLFPACK - 200910242300
Alumni: ADVANCED-2603102400
Alumni: ADVANCED HSSR -0805102300
Participated in Basic FC Seminar: FC BASIC-20091114
#47
Posted 20 July 2010 - 04:47 AM
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com//e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?129615]WOLFPACKS-3005090030 CALDAK'S SCENIC ROUTE [/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?163357]SCREWED'S REVENGE [/link]
[link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/////e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?210439]Advanced/HSSR Combo[/link]
#48
Posted 20 July 2010 - 09:02 PM
...that mach killmail is unfair, 4bil and most of the class didn't get on the killmail :sad:. interceptors taking out a mach by themselves?...
They weren't *all* interceptors. I (the person who showed up as a pod) was in a rupture. If I had played it right, I might have actually survived, but I was webbing drones to kill them faster to try and keep the 'ceptors alive (although not shooting at them with guns... just using drones), and he was able to minimize transversal enough to tear me up.
On the minus side, I died. On the plus side, at least *I* was on the km .
[link=http://agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?161954]BASIC-20091121[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?168868]WOLFPACKS-20091215[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?185995]ADVANCED-2603102400[/link] | [link=http://www.agony-unleashed.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?195531]ADVANCED HSSR -0805102300[/link]
#49
Posted 21 July 2010 - 06:05 PM
MORAL, adj. Conforming to a local and mutable standard of right. Having the quality of general expediency.